With midterm elections less than two weeks away, Senate candidates Andy Barr and Charles Booker held their only debate to convince Kentucky voters they should be the ones to replace retiring Sen. Mitch McConnell.
Topics ranged from immigration, gun safety and healthcare to the war with Iran, the Epstein files and the growing number of data centers.
Gas and energy prices
It began with the rise of gas prices to more than $4 a gallon, with diesel at more than $6 a gallon.
Barr said he wants to restore the American dream for his children and all Americans, and to do that would mean bringing down the prices of gas, food, housing, everything. He said he and other members of Congress are working on it and are making a lot of progress.
“[We are] digging out of the disastrous policies of the Biden administration and partisan overspending by congressional Democrats that gave us the highest inflation in a generation,” Barr said.
Barr said that’s why he supported the biggest tax cut in American history, which he claimed gives $2,800 to the average Kentucky taxpayer. He said Booker opposes this cut and would support the largest tax increase in American history.
Booker said he knows the rise in gas prices is on many Kentuckians’ minds. He told Kentuckians that this debate may be the first time they are having the chance to hear from him and Barr.
“One thing I know is that change is still possible, and the mountains can still be healed,” Booker said.
He said one way to bring down gas prices is to “stop the madness in Iran.”
Booker called Barr a “rubber stamp” for signing a blank check to keep the “madness” going, and noted the conflict started under Barr’s watch while in Congress, as has the rising cost of groceries.
Booker said that is something that he feels deeply about. Booker has three daughters, and said he tries to put fewer groceries in his cart, but it still costs more.
Booker blames the “chaos” in Washington.
He said that when he is the next U.S. senator of Kentucky, he will work to bring down the cost of food to put more money in people’s pockets.
Barr said he understands the diesel prices are having a ripple effect and hurting people, farmers particularly. But 80% of oil exports from the Strait of Hormuz have been restored to pre-war levels thanks to the U.S. Navy, he said. The claim is widely reported to be true, but the recovery has not had the effect of lowering prices because the region remains unstable.
“If you think diesel and gas prices are high now, wait until he [Booker] bans fossil energy with the Green New Deal. Life will be totally unaffordable,” Barr said.
Healthcare reform
Barr said he understands Kentuckians are dissatisfied with the current healthcare system, particularly coverage levels and prices.
“The answer is not more government, more bureaucratic control. The answer is restoring the doctor-patient relationship, competition, choice and innovation in healthcare,” Barr said.
Barr supports Medicare for seniors, but not for all, as Booker does.
Barr said that Booker wants Medicare for illegal immigrants and people who “didn’t pay into Medicare to take resources away from seniors.”
Booker believes that everyone deserves the same high-quality healthcare that members of Congress, like McConnell and Barr, are getting.
“If corrupt politicians can have high-quality healthcare in Kentucky, so should you,” Booker said.
Booker noted that Barr used his vote in Congress to cut nearly a trillion dollars from Medicaid, which could close more than 30 rural hospitals, a figure backed by analysis from the Sheps Center for Health Service Research at the University of North Carolina.
Booker said he knows what it feels like to choose between food on the table and buying the medication you need to live. He accused Barr of selling out to Wall Street and pharmaceutical companies.
“That’s why he’s okay with gutting your healthcare to help billionaires get richer,” Booker said.
Barr argued back, saying that he just does not want illegal immigrants, fraudsters and capable adults to take scarce resources from the people Medicaid was made for.
“The truth is, we want people to graduate out of Medicaid if they are work-capable and eligible to work because they can get health insurance, better health insurance through work,” Barr said.
Gun violence
Last week, a 16-year-old killed three children and a teacher in an Oregon elementary school’s special-needs classroom before an armed parent intervened and killed the shooter.
Booker said he is heartbroken and he cannot imagine the pain of losing children because of senseless violence when they are at school, where they should be safe.
Booker said that Barr has trampled over the Constitution, the First Amendment and the Second Amendment because he does not believe that the people’s rights matter.
“I think we need to make sure that children are not getting access to these firearms that could harm them. I believe that we should make sure people are having background checks. I believe we can make sure that weapons of war are not on the streets,” Booker said.
Barr also used the word heartbroken, saying he grieves with the families of the victims, and as a father, this is the ultimate nightmare. He also said he is thankful a good Samaritan, who was armed, was able to intervene and take out the shooter.
Over his time in Congress, Barr said, he voted for many measures to get to the root of the problem.
“I supported a legislation called the Helping Families in Mental Health Crisis Act to make sure that we can intervene with young people who are suffering from mental illness and to make sure that those individuals do not have access to firearms,” Barr said.
Barr also said that he has worked for school safety and voted many times on a multi-part piece of legislation called the Stop School Violence Act that provided a program to give school safety grants. He said he was able to secure some of those grants for some schools in Central Kentucky.
Barr called Booker a “soft-on-crime politician” who wants to defund the police.
Booker disagreed, saying that he has been clear for years that we need to fully fund community safety, which includes preventative measures, listening to leaders on the ground, law enforcement, youth and faith leaders and families that are impacted.
Data centers
Barr said data centers were necessary to compete with China’s AI industry, but Kentuckians should not have to pay higher electric or utility bills or worry about their water quality, which is why he voted in favor of the Ratepayer Protection Act in Congress, which passed in the House before Senate Democrats blocked the bill.
“What that bill would do is make sure that a company developing a data center would not be able to pass along higher costs on ratepayers, residential ratepayers, or small businesses that they would have to pay for any additional electricity that they consume,” Barr said.
Booker said that what Barr really wants to do is put a data center in Kentuckians’ backyards while acting as if he cares about the voices of Kentuckians, something Barr denied.
Booker said that Barr actually gets paid by telecom companies that would like to put data centers in many communities.
Barr argued he supports local control. He said that data centers do not belong in every community.
Flock cameras, crime and the Epstein files
Booker said he believes there must be very clear parameters and regulations in place for Flock cameras. He has heard the people of Kentucky who are concerned, and said Congress has to stand against the use of mass surveillance.
“I know law enforcement needs every tool to do their job. We have to make sure that the rights and liberties of the people of Kentucky are protected. Truthfully, we deserve to be safe,” Booker said.
Barr said that he finds the conversation illustrates the distinction in this race: “common sense versus crazy.”
He said that there should be guardrails on Flock cameras to make sure data collected from them is expunged after some time or deleted.
Barr said that Booker opposes the use of Flock cameras to apprehend criminals because he wants to defund police and does not support law enforcement because he wants to early release criminals.
Booker said Barr is lying and asked why Barr has not taken any action to make sure the Epstein files are fully released.
“He’s protecting child predators. I’m standing up for holistic approaches to community safety, which includes law enforcement. It is absolutely ridiculous to conclude that a father of three girls in this Commonwealth does not want us to be safe,” Booker said.
Barr argued that he did vote to release the Epstein files.
Mitch McConnell’s legacy
When asked if he would take the same or a different approach as McConnell, Booker said that you should not be in Congress to become rich. He said that Barr became a multimillionaire while in Washington.
Booker also noted how long McConnell has been in office, and said term limits should be in place.
Barr said that he is his own man and is proud of that, but he thinks McConnell deserves a lot of credit for defending the First Amendment and opposing what he called radical ideas like Booker’s, who he said supports compelling taxpayers to fund political campaigns.
“He’s a socialist in every respect, including supporting welfare for himself and forcing you to fund his political campaign; he’s fighting for himself. I’m fighting for you,” Barr said.
The war in Iran
Something that has been on Kentuckians’ minds has been two local U.S. service members dying during the conflict with Iran. The candidates were asked what the American exit strategy should look like by this point and whether the objective of getting rid of the threat of Iran having a nuclear weapon has been accomplished.
Barr expressed his condolences to the families of Sergeant Benjamin Pennington and Technical Sergeant Ashley Pruitt and to all of the fallen U.S. soldiers and said their sacrifice brought down the Iranian military.
“Their air force has been destroyed. Their economy is in ruins. The Ayatollah is dead. Their nuclear infrastructure is under rubble,” Barr said.
Booker said that the only reason Barr thinks the Iran war is a success is that “his billionaire friends are getting rich off of it.”
“I believe we need to end endless war. I believe we need to stand up for our seniors, for our veterans, for our service members, for those who have sacrificed for this country,” Booker said.
Immigration
The candidates weighed in on how they would balance border security while also meeting the workforce needs of Kentucky employers, mainly in the agriculture industry.
“I believe we need pathways to citizenship,” Booker said. “I believe we need to address the backlog in the court system that has so many people here pursuing the American dream, doing everything we would ask for them to do, and their only infraction is paperwork that is out of date.”
Booker said Barr is using his voice right now while in Congress to fund ICE, which he characterized as a “rogue vigilante group that is not protecting the border.”
“They’re not keeping you safe. They’re masked, unnamed men roaming the streets, killing American citizens like Alex Pretti, trampling on the Constitution, and terrorizing communities.” Booker said.
Barr claimed that 12 million people had been pouring over our border, with some of them not just from Mexico or Central or South America, but from countries he called adversarial, such as China and the Middle East.
Barr said that, thanks to the work of Republicans in Congress and the administration, that is not happening anymore.
“There have been zero releases in 16 months, and we have a secure border. And of course, we need to address any kind of problems that there are, if there is misconduct with ICE,” Barr said.
Booker said we need to invest in Border Patrol, which means work is done to protect our communities. Booker said that he believes we need “immigration rooted in humanity.”
Barr said that he thinks illegal immigrants are ripping off American taxpayers, and that fraud is rampant. And if the border were more secure, this would not happen.
Kentuckians can cast their vote for Senator at the polls on Nov. 3.
